Members | Sign In
All Forums > Off-topic
avatar

Aircraft Carriers in Space (Article)

posted Sep 29, 2012 01:04:23 by emblemamerica
Just read this great little article where a US Naval analyst critiques space combat. Thought you all might like to read it.

http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2012/09/28/aircraft_carriers_in_space?page=0,0
page   1
4 replies
avatar
ScottDunphy said Sep 29, 2012 13:02:56
Thanks, that was a really good article!
avatar
Shades4355 said Oct 01, 2012 02:36:16
That was a really interesting article. Thank you for sharing it!


Captain: [Shades], fire at will.
Weapons: Pst, hey, engineering....can I get more power to my tubes?
Eng: Sure?
*nearly 20 homing missiles in rapid succession, plus one nuke*
Sci: .....All enemies destroyed....
avatar
GeorgeC.Bragg said Oct 02, 2012 18:47:46
From the article: " If you do a fairly simple extrapolation of current technology, what you end up with is space combat as sort of ponderous ballet with shots fired at long distance at fairly fragile targets where you have to predict where the target is going to be. You don't end up with space fighters. You don't end up with lots of armaments. "

Anyone here read Jack Campbell's "Lost Fleet" series? (Well, okay, really John G. Hemry...) That's pretty much his scenario, with a few adjustments. Their weapons include "hell-lance" energy weapons (for shorter range work, iirc), missiles, and good old "grapeshot" (which, given that ships are moving at a measurable fraction of the speed of light, can cause incredible damage should you slam into it before you see it coming). But ship formations do high-speed passes at each other rather than 'sniping' from long distance, so that's a difference from the article.

It's interesting how, when ships arrive in a new sector (via jump gates) in 'his universe', they start to calculate how long until the ships in orbit around the system's sun can see them, based on being so many light-minutes out, etc. His space battles tend to be a bit more three-dimensional than most, as well, and he seems to have thought out 3D ship formations fairly well.
avatar
Hissatsu said Oct 03, 2012 13:41:50
Thanks!
Login below to reply: